War Room: Improving, but list creation still painful Review

Add reviewWar Room: Improving, but list creation still painful Good reviewsWar Room: Improving, but list creation still painful Bad reviewsWar Room: Improving, but list creation still painful Review RSS feed
War Room has 229 reviews. Enter your email below and we'll notify you when new reviews are added, so you can comment, share or remove the reviews. This is great for monitoring your apps or the competition's apps
Improving, but list creation still painful
Many of the most egregious bugs have been fixed in this release. However, the app still feels slow, even on the new iPad (iPad3) and iPhone 4S. Overall, the UI shows a million concessions as a design-by-comittee approach collided with a one-size-fits-all cross-platform interface. Text regularly overlaps controls. The text entry is questionable at best as you type into both a nonstandard text field as well as a standard one that pops up atop the keyboard. Parts of the interface do not scroll where appropriate, so the keyboard covers up the fields you are entering text into. To get to the next field you must dismiss the keyboard, find the next field and continue on. The list building workflow is excruciating. The application does almost no filtering of available models beyond showing only your faction and mercenaries. The claim is to allow "free form" list building, but by eliminating some illegal list options (like other factions) and allowing others (adding mercenary 'jacks to a non-merc caster), it causes unnecessary confusion. Regardless of what was advertised, what users want is an application that will assist them with list building, not dumbly accept any nonsense you put in. PP wanted a one-and-done application and are unwilling to put in the effort to update the app for future changes that would be required by adding some list-building assistance. This is and will continue to be it's greatest failing. The card library may contain errors and it's important to double-check anything important, which really kills the concept of having the cards in your pocket. The Rule Reference section cannot be searched, you have to know the title you are looking for, which is inconvenient. Limitations to be aware of: -Army lists cannot be shared between devices. (Supposedly this will be coming in a future update.) -There is a limit of three devices per account. (Up from the original limit of 2) -It will do very little filtering/math for you. Theme forces that change point costs, for example will not be handled automatically. -You have to re-login every time the app is killed and relaunched, it apparently can't remember your password between launches. -At launch you suffer through three splash screens and then a loading screen.
MRRSoftware on Aug 16, 2012 for War Room
share · comment
Interface and Cost
Previous observation fixed: I can log on now. Only took 10 days. However, now I find that I cannot use this application. Without spending $7 minimum, this app does not even function as an army builder, let alone a game utility. That is not "free". Then consider the $7 per faction deck price point. $7 for faction decks that I bought once in 2002, once in 2006, and a third time in 2010. The last two times, these decks were $19 each. And this time, I won't even actually own them. Each deck should be $1 and stores on the device-- or free with a $20 price on the app.
Mister Plug on Aug 16, 2012 for War Room
share · comment
Needs improvement.
So far this app is not very good. It's slow it's buggy and it doesn't seem to want to cooperate. While I understand that my device may be part of the problem, it still doesn't explain why I can't even so much as make a list without the thing bugging out forcing me to close the app. So far I have only played with it and I will not purchase a single faction deck until the app is in better working condition.
Cyberpicke223 on Aug 16, 2012 for War Room
share · comment
Feels like a work in progress
Needs some optimization.
Robert Kukuchka on Aug 16, 2012 for War Room
share · comment
A good start...
Over all this is a great start. Hopefully you will make the few changes needed to bring this over the top to become a great tool both on and off the table top. However the point of view that was given in the road map of this being a card library more then an army list construction tool is a little aggravating. It was presented as one. A great and functional one was removed to be replaced with this was a tad bit annoying. A few changes that are needed to make this a great system: 1.) make the tier system effect the list creation system. It's a small thing but it has become a big part of the game. 2.) when building a list if you have more then one caster change the FA of a unit to match. If I am playing an unbound game, I'd like to field my full allotment of units with out the app saying it is not valid. 3.)...... Ok let's face it. Make this work like a list construction tool. It's one of the key things it was presented as. A great FREE program was removed to be replaced with this system. It's a start but please make this main function of the app work like it should. Allow us to make a list and have it verify that it is a legal one. Support the theme list function of the game. OR Allow iBodger to be supported again just to makes lists and nothing else. The other functions are great. Easy to control mid game and actually nicer to use then the real cards.
E2lio2tR on Aug 15, 2012 for War Room
share · comment
So. Much. Fail.
Open an API and let the community have a crack at it. They will do a much better job. Failhouse is made of fail.
Bovard T on Aug 12, 2012 for War Room
share · comment